REVIEW KOMPREHENSIF: STUDI PERBANDINGAN MATERIAL SS304 DAN FRP PENGGANTI SS400 PADA PIPA DUCTING SCRUBBING PABRIK NPK-1 PT PUSRI PALEMBANG

  • Vidia Tanaya Putri Universitas Jambi
  • Latifatul Rohmah Universitas Jambi
  • Afdal Mukminin Universitas Jambi
  • Aldillah Herlambang Universitas Jambi
  • Oki Alfernando Universitas Jambi
  • Rizka Shafira Universitas Jambi
Keywords: Material, Piping, FRP, Ducting, SS304

Abstract

Failure of the Carbon Steel SS400 scrubbing ducting pipe in the NPK-1 Plant of PT Pusri Palembang due to internal corrosion and solid accumulation highlights the need to evaluate more reliable replacement materials to improve operational reliability and prevent unscheduled shutdowns. This study aims to compare the performance of Stainless Steel 304 (SS304) and Fiber Reinforced Plastic (FRP) as alternative substitutes for SS400 through a comprehensive literature review approach. The research method employed a literature review by collecting and analyzing secondary data from various national and international scientific publications, followed by a comparative assessment of both materials based on technical, economic, environmental, and safety aspects using a weighted multi-criteria scoring matrix. The results indicate that FRP Vinylester has dominant advantages in corrosion resistance under aggressive NPK fluid environments, lower life cycle costs, and better operational efficiency, achieving a weighted score of 7.63 compared to 6.86 for SS304. However, SS304 demonstrates advantages in fire safety, inspectability, structural integrity, and suitability for areas with high safety requirements. These findings suggest that no single material is absolutely superior across all parameters, but FRP is more optimal as the primary material for most ducting segments, while SS304 is recommended for critical segments through a hybrid approach. The implications of this study provide a multi-criteria-based material selection recommendation to improve scrubbing system reliability, long-term cost efficiency, process safety, and support more sustainable asset management strategies in the fertilizer industry.

References

Adkins, L. (2022). Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Resin and Corrosion Barrier Selection – the Testing behind the Recommendation. CONFERENCE 2022, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.5006/C2022-17961
Alrehaili, E., Nurdiawati, A., & Al-Ghamdi, S. G. (2025). Sustainable composites for metal replacement: Environmental assessment and material selection of fiber-reinforced polymer across industries. Resources, Conservation & Recycling Advances, 28, 200294. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2025.200294
Apriliana, A. D., Liman, L., Erwanto, E., & Muhtarudin, M. (2025). PENGARUH KOMBINASI PUPUK TRICHOKOMPOS DAN PUPUK NPK TERHADAP KANDUNGAN PROTEIN KASAR DAN SERAT KASAR RUMPUT PAKCHONG. Jurnal Riset Dan Inovasi Peternakan (Journal of Research and Innovation of Animals), 9(3), 453–463. https://doi.org/10.23960/jrip.2025.9.3.453-463
Athallah, M. N., Yudo, H., & Zakki, A. F. (2025). Analisa Pengaruh Variasi Arus Las SMAW Pada Pengelasan Dissimilar Baja ST42 dan SS304 Terhadap Laju Korosi dan Kekuatan Impak. Jurnal Teknik Perkapalan, 13(4), 1–10. https://ejournal3.undip.ac.id/index.php/naval
Inayah, R., Pratiwi, W. D., & Indrawan, R. (2023). Efek Sinergis Alumina Trihydrate Dan Melamine Cyanurate Terhadap Ketahanan Api Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer (GFRP). Jurnal Engine: Energi, Manufaktur, Dan Material, 7(1), 21–27.
Kurniasari, A. P., & Amalia, Y. (2022). Pengaruh Korosi Terhadap Kegagalan Logam pada Jembatan : Literature Review. Jurnal Mekanik Terapan, 3(2), 65–69. https://doi.org/10.32722/jmt.v3i2.4597
Maulana, M. R., & Rokhim, I. N. (2026). Analisa Kekuatan Material dan Biaya Produksi FRP (Fiber Reinforced Plastic) dengan Subtitusi Serat Rami Nanas. JOURNAL SAINS STUDENT RESEARCH, 4(2), 83–95. https://doi.org/10.61722/jssr.v4i2.9355
Nasrah, P., & Homzah, O. F. (2023). ANALISA KERUSAKAN PIPA DUCTING SCRUBBING BERBAHAN CARBON STEEL SS400 DI PABRIK PUPUK NPK-1 PT PUSRI PALEMBANG. AUSTENIT, 15(1), 55–62. https://doi.org/10.53893/austenit.v15i1.6684
Nurcholis, I., Pratiwi, W. D., Karim, M., Amin, A., Anggara, D., Wahyu, E., Teknik, J., Kapal, B., Perkapalan, P., Surabaya, N., & Kimia, J. T. (2022). Analisis komparasi kekerasan dan struktur mikro lasan dissimilar material pada berbagai posisi pengelasan di industri fabrikasi. Journal of Welding Technology, 4(1), 1–8.
Nurwahyudin, H., Atros, M. R. El, & Mualif. (2025). Analisis Pengaruh Pengaturan Parameter pada CNC Cutting Laser terhadap Kualitas Hasil Pemotongan pada Material Stainless Steel 304 di PT X. Jurnal Engine: Energi, Manufaktur, Dan Material, 9(1), 121–130. https://doi.org/10.30588/jeemm.v9i1.2164
Omar, S. Al, & Abdelhadi, A. (2024). Comparative Life-Cycle Assessment of Steel and GFRP Rebars for Procurement Sustainability in the Construction Industry. Sustainability, 16(10), 3899. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16103899
Sbahieh, S., Mckay, G., & Al-Ghamdi, S. G. (2023). A comparative life cycle assessment of fiber-reinforced polymers as a sustainable reinforcement option in concrete beams. Frontiers in Built Environment, 9. https://doi.org/10.3389/fbuil.2023.1194121
Sianipar, D., Suprihanto, A., & Haryadi, G. D. (2024). PENGARUH KEKASARAN STAINLESS STEEL TIPE 304 YANG DIGUNAKAN UNTUK KAWAT ORTODONTIK TERHADAP LAJU KOROSI PADA LARUTAN SALIVA BUATAN. Jurnal Teknik Mesin S-1, 12(2), 25–36.
Soto-Vázquez, R. (2025). Life-cycle assessment in mining and mineral processing: A bibliometric overview. Green and Smart Mining Engineering, 2(1), 73–83. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsme.2025.02.001
Sultan, M. A., AR, R., & Gaus, A. (2022). Efek Perkuatan Glass Fiber Reinforce Polymer Sheet Pada Balok Beton Bertulang Dengan Tulangan Korosi. Teras Jurnal : Jurnal Teknik Sipil, 12(1), 103–116. nhttps://doi.org/10.29103/tj.v12i1.694
Zatkalíková, V., Uhríčik, M., Markovičová, L., & Kuchariková, L. (2022). Corrosion Behavior of Sensitized AISI 304 Stainless Steel in Acid Chloride Solution. Materials, 15(23), 8543. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma15238543
Zayadi, A., Sugkono, & HP, C. (2021). Analisis Radiografi Sinar-X Terhadap Sambungan Pelat Baja Tahan Karat Aisi 304 Hasil Pengelasan Tungsten Inert Gas Dengan Arus 40-60 Ampere. Jurnal Teknologi Kedirgantaraan, 6(2). https://doi.org/10.35894/jtk.v6i2
Published
2026-05-18
How to Cite
Vidia Tanaya Putri, Latifatul Rohmah, Afdal Mukminin, Aldillah Herlambang, Oki Alfernando, & Rizka Shafira. (2026). REVIEW KOMPREHENSIF: STUDI PERBANDINGAN MATERIAL SS304 DAN FRP PENGGANTI SS400 PADA PIPA DUCTING SCRUBBING PABRIK NPK-1 PT PUSRI PALEMBANG. EDU RESEARCH, 7(1), 3331-3340. https://doi.org/10.47827/jer.v7i1.2454
Section
Articles