ANALISIS PERBANDINGAN QUANTITY TAKE-OFF (QTO) PEKERJAAN STRUKTUR KOLOM BETON DENGAN METODE KONVENSIONAL DAN AUTODESK REVIT (STUDI KASUS: PERENCANAAN HOTEL LIMA LANTAI DI SUKABUMI)
Abstract
Quantity Take-Off (QTO) is a crucial phase in construction project management to determine material quantities and budget allocations. Accuracy in QTO significantly affects project success by preventing cost overruns or material shortages. This study aims to analyze and compare QTO results for concrete column structural works using conventional methods based on Microsoft Excel and Building Information Modeling (BIM) based on Autodesk Revit 2026. The case study is a five-story hotel building design in Sukabumi with a total building area of 1,896.12 m². The results demonstrate that both methods yield identical quantity values with zero variance (0.00% deviation). The total concrete volume is 156.23 m³, the formwork area is 2,075 m², and the reinforcement bar weights (diameters D19, Ø12, Ø10, Ø8, Ø6) are perfectly consistent across both methods. Although the quantity accuracy is equivalent, Autodesk Revit offers a significant advantage in time efficiency, minimizes manual data entry risks (human error), and provides three-dimensional model visualization to detect structural element clashes easily. In conclusion, adopting BIM through Autodesk Revit is highly recommended to improve the productivity of construction cost estimation.

